Free evidence checklist · Updated 11 Nov 2026

Product not as described? Start with a verifiable mismatch.

A listing said one thing, but the item in your hands shows another. The most useful first step is not a longer complaint: it is a short record that someone else can verify.

1. Preserve the exact advertised claim

Capture the product page showing the claim, model or variant, seller name, date if visible, and enough context to show the relevant listing. Preserve the original image or page capture and your order confirmation. A claim copied from memory is weaker than an exact screenshot.

2. Document what you actually received

Photograph the label, box, manual and the product itself, particularly the model and specification markings. For performance claims, record your testing method, the date, operating conditions and result. If you cannot verify a number, say so rather than guessing.

3. Create a claim-by-claim evidence matrix

AdvertisedObservedOriginal proof to attach
Up to 30 hours battery life8 hours under a documented test settingListing capture A, test log B
IPX7 water resistanceBox identifies IPX4Listing capture A, packaging photo C

Fictional illustration only. Your claim must use your own accurate observations and source files.

4. Check for alternative explanations

These checks keep the complaint factual. A genuine misunderstanding is better resolved early than escalated on a weak claim.

5. Write a short requested remedy

State the order, the exact discrepancy, where it appears in the attachments, and what outcome you request. Avoid legal threats, invented deadlines, exaggerated damages or claims you cannot prove. Submit through the marketplace's current official order or dispute channel; its time limits and evidence requirements may vary.

Privacy tip: Do not post order numbers, addresses, receipts or message screenshots publicly. Use the private tool to assemble a full case; share only a reviewed, redacted summary with communities.

6. Keep an evidence index

Name files descriptively: A_listing_claim.png, B_product_label.jpg, C_test_log.txt. Each mismatch should point to one or more specific files. Never modify an original screenshot to make the claim look stronger.

Build a free, private evidence packet →